Everyday sedans. Year, engine and mileage, please. Request an account
Home/Buying and auctions/A commuter car for my college kid

A commuter car for my college kid: the insurance quote, whose name goes on the title, and an out of state repo in Texas

Started by sophomore_dad_mike on Sep 5, 2025in Buying and auctions6 posts
sophomore_dad_mikeOP
New plates
Lubbock, TX
drives 2014 Malibu 2.5, 139k miles
6 posts, joined Sep 2025
9:50 PM#1

mike, lubbock. my daughter is a sophomore at tech, lives off 19th with two roommates and works afternoons at a clinic out on quaker. she has been driving my wife's car since january and that arrangement has run out of road.

budget is 15,000 cash. no payment, no co-signing, i am not doing either of those at 19. i have read the camry thread on this board twice and made an account mostly so i could ask the things nobody around me can answer with a number.

there is a 2021 corolla LE with 41,000 miles listed at M and A right now, which is the repo auction that thread is about, closing friday. i have been looking at m&a auto sales for about a week and reading more than i have been bidding.

what i cannot get a straight answer on:

  • insurance. she is 19. does she go on my policy with the car in my name, or does she need her own policy? my agent gave me a number on the phone and i have no idea whether it is normal or whether i am being quoted the lazy version.
  • whose name on the title. if it is in her name she owns it and i have no say in how it is insured. if it is in mine, what happens in two years when she graduates and moves, and does signing it over to her then cost me the sales tax a second time?
  • the car is titled in another state and i am in texas. what does the county want from me and how long do i have to do it?
night_shift_nurse_kay
Daily driver
Phoenix, AZ
drives 2016 Sentra SV, 141k miles
18 posts, joined Aug 2025
8:15 AM#2

i did this four years ago with my son. arizona is not texas but the insurance half is the same everywhere.

adding him to my policy, with the car titled to me, was far cheaper than a separate policy in his name. it was still the biggest single jump in any bill i have ever gotten. the thing that moved the number most was not him, it was the car. the same kid on a corolla and on a mustang are two different quotes and it is not close. a boring car with good crash scores and no power is about as cheap as a 19 year old gets.

ask your agent two things people forget. does the good student discount apply, we got 14 percent for a B average and nobody mentioned it until i asked. and is she rated as the primary driver of that car or as an occasional driver on yours. the honest answer to that second one costs money and the convenient answer gets a claim denied at the worst moment of your life.

toyota_master_tech_ben
Commuter
Charlotte, NC
drives 2017 Camry XSE V6, 96k miles
118 posts, joined Aug 2025
2:30 PM#3

nobody has said anything about the car itself so i will. a 2021 corolla LE is the 2.0 with the cvt that has a physical launch gear in it, and it is the hardest thing on your list to kill. i am a toyota tech, so of course i said corolla, and the elantra and the forte in that money are fine cars that i would not argue about.

on a 41,000 mile one i would want three numbers before i bid: brake pad thickness front and rear, because a kid driving in town eats brakes and that is a 500 dollar surprise in february; the date codes on the tires, since a 2021 car has four year old rubber on it no matter how the tread looks; and whether the cabin filter has ever been changed, which tells you how the last owner treated everything you cannot see.

ask for a photo of the brake rotor edge and one of the tire sidewall. if whoever is listing it will send those, the rest of the listing is probably honest too.

dayton_commuter
Daily driver
Dayton, OH
drives 2023 Camry SE, 11k miles
14 posts, joined Aug 2025
6:40 PM#4

mine is the thread you have been reading. on your third question, from ohio, so the names are different but the shape is the same.

the out of state title came from the bank with the assignment and the lien release on it, and my county would not touch it until somebody had looked at the vin in person. that was one extra stop and a few dollars. call the lubbock county tax office and ask specifically whether texas wants a vin verification on an out of state vehicle and where they want it done, and ask before you bid, not after you win. mine was a ten minute detour on a saturday. in some counties it is an appointment three weeks out, and three weeks of temp tags and insurance on a car your kid cannot drive yet is the real cost.

and ask how many keys. i paid 155 for the second one and i am going to keep saying it in every thread until somebody saves themselves the money.

sophomore_dad_mikeOP
New plates
Lubbock, TX
drives 2014 Malibu 2.5, 139k miles
6 posts, joined Sep 2025
7:05 AM#5

took me longer than i meant to. here is everything, since mod_tanya_r says this board runs on numbers.

insurance. my agent ran it three ways on a 2021 corolla. hallie added to our policy with the car titled to me: 1,184 for six months, up from the 612 we pay now. her own policy on the same car in her name: 1,790 for six months. same coverage all three times, 100/300 liability and a 500 deductible, good student discount applied in each one. so she goes on ours and the car goes in my name, which answers my second question for me whether i like the answer or not.

one thing that saved 94 dollars: when i gave them her real annual mileage, 6,000, instead of the 12,000 they default to. nobody asks. you have to volunteer it.

the title. lubbock county tax office, and the woman at the counter was better than anything online. a vehicle titled in another state needs a vin verification before texas will title it, done at an inspection station, and you bring that paper with you. then form 130-U, the out of state title signed over, proof of insurance, and motor vehicle sales tax of 6.25 percent of what i paid. thirty days from the date of sale, and she was clear that thirty days means thirty days and not thirty five.

the part i did not know and the reason i am typing this out: when she graduates and i sign the car over to her, a transfer between a parent and a child is a gift. that is a ten dollar gift tax and a form, not another 6.25 percent. so putting it in my name today does not cost her a second tax bill in 2027. i could not get that answer out of anybody i know and the woman at the counter had it in nine seconds.

the corolla i was watching closed on the 12th and i did not put a number on it, because none of this was settled yet and i was not going to bid on a car i might not be able to register. i emailed m&a monday about a 2021 LE with 38,000 miles that closes next week and had the mileage and the key count back the same afternoon, two keys on that one. the m&a auction gets one number from me, 14,200, and if i lose it i lose it. i am not raising my bid for a car for a 19 year old and now i have said that in public so i have to live with it.

mod_tanya_r
Moderator
Des Moines, IA
drives 2016 Accord Sport, 198k miles
86 posts, joined Aug 2025
12:55 PM#6

two things from the service counter side of the world and then this can sit quietly.

whose name is on the title does not matter until the day there is a wreck. if the car is titled to you and she is listed on your policy as the driver of that car, the insurance company has no argument available to it. if the car is titled to her and she is a driver on your policy, they have one, and they will make it at the worst possible moment, in writing, six weeks later. you landed in the right place for the right reason.

the other thing. when you buy it, come back and post the whole number. the price, the tax, the verification fee, the plates, the first set of brakes. every september and october there are parents reading this board who cannot find a straight answer anywhere about what a car for a kid actually costs, and yours would be the first one on the internet with the fees in it.

Log in to reply. No account yet? Ask for one, it takes a day or two.

Threads people read after this one

Tags

  • first car
  • teen insurance
  • title in whose name
  • Texas registration
  • Form 130-U
  • out of state repo